Personal or Public…The Moral Debate - Instablogs
Personal or Public…The Moral Debate
Saira Sayani , Pune: Jun 7 2008
Made Popular Jun 8 2008
India :

Personal or Public…The Moral DebateI had a very strange, quite surreal, experience yesterday…Two educated, well brought up people working at one of the top companies in India asked me some shocking questions. I was stunned and amazed not at the questions as much as the attitude and method of cross questioning. Here’s the first question…brace yourself.

“Why do we need plants and trees? We have made so much progress, so many forests have been replaced by industrial development, and we are still alive. What difference would it make to have a world without greenery? Nothing personal…just saying.”
It took me a moment to reorient myself. Such was the shocking, impact of this statement. The environmentalist in me didn’t like it one bit and I was surprised by my own reaction. Oh this is personal, very personal!

Why do we need trees? Hello? Where do you get the oxygen from? The breeze you enjoy during hot suffocating summers? Global emissions have actually risen by 24 per cent mainly due to green house gas emissions. There will be a five-degree increase in temperature over the next hundred years. Vast stretches of coastal India may just go under water if we don’t take some serious steps, large areas will be submerged and displace around fifty million people in India alone.

The world was created keeping a certain balance in place, nature provided us with the necessary tools to survive and progress. What have we done and still continue doing?

Taking from Mother Nature like ungrateful brutes and destroying the only source we’ve got left to survive. How many hours do we work in a day? Ecosystems maintain an equilibrium, flora and fauna work 24/7 to provide us with the comforts that we are taking for granted. Where do you think you are getting your fax, printouts and photocopies from? The newspapers you read everyday, the magazines you flip while waiting at the salon? These materials come from the trees that are being chopped left, right and centre. At the end of the month you take your salary home using nature’s resources, and what do you give back?
India is rapidly growing into a rich consumer class which has made the country the 12th largest luxury market in the world. The other side of the coin… The richest consumer classes produce 4.5 times more CO2 than the poorest class, and almost 3 times more than the average.

These people fire the statements but can’t reply once we start asking the real questions. Because we just don’t ask the questions, we find the solutions and give the answers with the facts not frills.

Blue Alert, one of the hottest campaigns of Greenpeace is focusing on just that. Engaging people through posting climate hazard signs, slapping eviction notices on buildings under threat of submergence and organizing climate migrant kiosks in high risk localities in the five coastal cities. Mumbai, Kochin, Chennai, Kolkata and Panjim.

Blue Alert – Climate Migrants in South Asia: Estimates and Solutions, a paper authored by Dr Sudhir Chella Rajan, professor of Humanities and Social Sciences at IIT Madras, and a climate expert, estimates the number of people who could be displaced from their homes at 125 million in India and Bangladesh alone. With Greenpeace by their side More than 5000 people have signed postcards of concern to their MPs.
Citizens, celebrities and politicians have joined the Blue Alert campaign...what are you waiting for? It’s time to stop asking and start acting.
It is very personal as I said at the beginning. Look at it from the macro levels as all should, you can bet your last breath on mother earth it’s not. It’s public!

Saira Sayani for Greenpeace

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Grace Calderon
Quezon City, Philippines
Pardon those stupid people who asked those stupid questions. They’re probably not from earth.

Hurray to Greenpeace for all their efforts! Given situations as the one above, we should ask Greenpeace to harness their environmental activism more by way of maximum information dissemination.

It’s ignorance that’s killing this planet.
1 Stars
Kushal Arora
Mumbai, India
That is the height of selfishness and ignorant attitude. Mind those people, if it werent for those trees who get replaced with industrial centers, they wouldnt breath fresh oxygen everyday. It is silly that those people forget that if you just take from the nature and not replenish it, such people would along with the entire world would have to find substitutes for fresh oxygen, anti soil erosion substance, wood, foods and many other vital things. Certainly one can see where the world is going with such unconcerned people in its wagon
1 Stars
A classy example of ‘Madness of few and loss of many’.
1 Stars
Manoj J
shimla, India
Never mind those ’i don’t care’ blokes. They will be around walking with their ignorant heads held high. but its the effort made by people like you and Greenpeace that will make a difference in making the planet greener.
1 Stars
Simply brilliant stuff, Ma’m Kudos to all your researches...
1 Stars
It is most surprising how a person can pose such a question.Does the person not experience the environment in his daily life.Let the person live in a barren cage for sometime to have the feel of living without trees.
1 Stars
Sameer Kumar
Hyderabad, India
Not surprising that there are people that think like that and to be honest there are many out there who feel exactly the same way, if not expressing it so blatantly. I know many who would trash the planet as long as the trash is out of their own house and many who go on a holiday and leave more back than they take home. It is a sad fact and in a developing nation like India, it is not as if the law is on our side when people trash the roads. If we want better order we need better laws too out here and of course the awareness too.
1 Stars
Sanjay
Pune, India
File Type: Image
Way to go!
You have it in you and the felicity with which you weave words to make a complete fabric is awesome, so are your views on the environment and of course the work you do with Greenpeace needs to be commended. Cheers and amen to that.
1 Stars
Milind
Thiruvananthapuram, India
nothing doing ppl. Just do one thing: put these ppl into a pit whereform they could not see the greenery and inhale the fresh air. just for a few seconds!! that will be enough for them to realize what importance greenery and trees have for us, not only to live but to live healthy.
1 Stars
Prabhunarayan
Pondicherry, India
yea they are right in saying so. coz they are getting everything to live at ease. however, they will not survive to see why they not say so. the coming generations will see this. with rising temperature and less rains, they will reap what these stupid people are sowing it present.
Add your Comment